World of Warcraft: ForeverComparação

Shadowfang Keep: weapon pick

Melee friend: Butcher's Cleaver. Caster: Blade of Silverlaine. These are WoW: Forever stats, not retail.

Butcher's Cleaver item icon

WoW: Forever

The stat line makes the split clear: cleaver for physical melee; Silverlaine's blade for spell damage.
WeaponBest fitVerified Forever details
Butcher's CleaverMelee1H axe; req. 20; 16.2 DPS; +5 Strength, +2 Agility. Razorclaw the Butcher.
Blade of SilverlaineCasterMain-hand sword; req. 21; +28 spell damage/healing, +6 Shadow Resistance. Baron Silverlaine.
Butcher's Cleaver item icon
Blade of Silverlaine item icon